Beyond Rest: Rethinking Concussion Recovery with Dr. Ayla Wolf - #44
Episode Show Notes
Guest: Dr. Ayla Wolf
Duration: ~48 minutes
Episode Description
Dr. Ayla Wolf shares her personal journey from sustaining multiple concussions to becoming a leading expert in concussion recovery. She challenges the outdated "rest in a dark room" advice and explains why persistent post-concussion syndrome requires an individualized, integrative approach combining neuroscience, functional neurology, and holistic therapies.
Timestamps
0:10 - Introduction
Welcome and episode overview
1:00 - Guest Introduction
Meet Dr. Ayla Wolf - clinician, researcher, and author
2:51 - Dr. Wolf's Personal Story
How multiple concussions changed her career path
7:31 - The Turning Point
Making the radical decision to return to school and study brain injuries
8:41 - What Happens After a Concussion
Understanding the brain's metabolic crisis and energy deficit
19:32 - Understanding Functional Neurology
How this approach differs from traditional assessments
25:23 - Acupuncture and Cerebral Blood Flow
The role of holistic therapies in concussion recovery
28:34 - Why Rest Isn't Always Best
Debunking the "dark room" myth and understanding gradual return to activity
31:56 - Dysautonomia Explained
The autonomic nervous system and its role in persistent symptoms
43:35 - The Concussion Breakthrough Book
A comprehensive guide for those feeling stuck in recovery
47:14 - Closing Thoughts & Resources
How to learn more and connect with Dr. Wolf
Key Takeaways
- Most concussions heal within weeks, but 30% of people develop persistent symptoms
- Prolonged rest beyond 48-72 hours can create maladaptive neuroplasticity
- Functional neurology provides individualized treatment based on comprehensive testing
- Dysautonomia (autonomic nervous system dysfunction) is common after concussion
- Recovery requires integrative approaches addressing multiple brain systems simultaneously
- Acupuncture can improve cerebral blood flow through the trigeminovascular system
Resources Mentioned
Dr. Wolf's website:
https://www.lifeafterimpact.com/
Book: The Concussion Breakthrough: Discover The Missing Pieces to Recovery
https://a.co/d/0bCKi38b
Podcast: Life After Impact: The Concussion Recovery Podcast
https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/life-after-impact-the-concussion-recovery-podcast/id1790456849
Organization: Healing Response Acupuncture and Functional Neurology
https://www.healingresponseneuro.com/
Guest Bio
Dr. Ayla Wolf is an associate professor at the Carrick Institute and founder of Healing Response Acupuncture and Functional Neurology. With over 20 years of experience working with complex neurological cases, she specializes in traumatic brain injury, chronic migraine, dysautonomia, and vestibular disorders. Her work combines neuroscience, functional neurology, and holistic therapies to help patients with persistent post-concussion syndrome.
Transcript
Welcome back to the Neurostimulation Podcast, the show where we explore
2
:the science and clinical practice
of non-invasive neurostimulation,
3
:interventional mental health, and
innovative approaches to improving
4
:general mental health and wellness
in order to help treat complex
5
:neurological and psychiatric conditions.
6
:I'm Michael Passmore, psychiatrist
and clinical associate professor
7
:in the Department of Psychiatry at
the University of British Columbia
8
:in beautiful Vancouver, Canada.
9
:Today's conversation focuses in on a
topic that is very common and often
10
:deeply misunderstood, concussion and
persistent post-concussion syndrome.
11
:My guest today is Dr.
12
:Ayla Wolf, a clinician and researcher who
has spent more than two decades working
13
:with complex neurological cases, including
things like traumatic brain injury.
14
:Chronic migraine dysautonomia
and vestibular disorders.
15
:Dr.
16
:Wolf's path into this
field is quite personal.
17
:After sustaining multiple concussions
herself, she experienced many neurological
18
:symptoms, things like depression, anxiety,
insomnia, brain fog, chronic pain.
19
:But instead of accepting that as her
new normal, she stepped away from
20
:her clinical practice and return
to school to study applied clinical
21
:neuroscience and functional neurology.
22
:And so that journey ultimately led
her to develop a highly integrative
23
:approach to neurological rehabilitation
that combines things like neuroscience,
24
:functional neurology, as well as
holistic approaches like acupuncture.
25
:Dr.
26
:Wolf is the author of the book, the
Concussion Breakthrough: Discover The
27
:Missing Pieces to Recovery, and she's
also the host of the podcast, Life
28
:After Impact, The Concussion Recovery
Podcast, where she interviews experts
29
:working on brain injury and recovery.
30
:Dr.
31
:Wolf is an associate professor
at the Kerrick Institute and
32
:the founder of Healing Response
Acupuncture and Functional Neurology.
33
:Dr.
34
:Wolf, thanks so much for joining
us and welcome to the podcast.
35
:Really looking forward
to the conversation.
36
:Ayla: Neuromodulation is what I
do all day long, so I was excited
37
:to be, be a guest on your show.
38
:MIke: Fantastic.
39
:Yeah.
40
:So I'm really curious.
41
:So many people working in brain
injury care arrived there because
42
:of a personal experience, and so,
really interested, to hear your story.
43
:So perhaps you could, help us
to understand that and explain
44
:a bit about that background.
45
:Ayla: Sure, I'll try to do it in a shorter
period of time 'cause sometimes in telling
46
:stories I can be a little long-winded.
47
:I think the best way to start out
is when I graduated from my master's
48
:program in Chinese medicine, I opened
up an acupuncture clinic and I actually
49
:specialized in fertility at the time.
50
:And so I was very interested in
functional medicine and functional
51
:endocrinology and, the crossroads of
how do you utilize acupuncture and
52
:Chinese medicine to support people in
hormonal bAylance who are trying to
53
:grow their families and get pregnant.
54
:And so I've always.
55
:I've always loved science.
56
:I've always loved functional approaches
to things, and so that my mindset was
57
:already thinking in that way of kind of
functional medicine meets acupuncture
58
:and Chinese medicine, which you could
say that Chinese medicine and Ayurvedic
59
:medicine really are the oldest forms
of functional medicine out there.
60
:So my brain was very much already thinking
in these terms, and over the years I
61
:had, I had several sports concussions
that I walked, I walked away from, I
62
:never had a concussion that had me back
boarded out of somewhere, or, you know,
63
:had immediate go to the urgent care and
get checked out because most of my sports
64
:were individual sports like mountain
biking, where when you crash, you crash
65
:15 miles in the forest and there's no
sideline athletic trainers watching you.
66
:Mm-hmm.
67
:And so a lot of my concussions were,
at Mount Bachelor, snowboarding,
68
:or in the woods mountain biking, or
on a lake somewhere wakeboarding.
69
:And then on top of that, I've got a
25 year history of martial arts where
70
:I've taken a lot of sub-concussive
hits to the head, getting choked out in
71
:jiujitsu, hypoxic injuries and insults.
72
:And so I think that my history of
sports concussions, created a situation
73
:that was a bit of a slow burn in
terms of symptoms and there were two
74
:concussions that happened 10 days apart.
75
:And in that moment, that was when I
experienced actual kind of speech aphasia.
76
:So for, I was flying, home and
I had three legs of my flight.
77
:And I remember after that second
concussion that had happened 10 days after
78
:the first I was at the airport and I just
couldn't figure out how to order a salad.
79
:Like I didn't have the words.
80
:And so I kind of remember just handing
the person my boxed salad and them
81
:asking me if I wanted a beverage
and I just kind of shook my head and
82
:handed them money and walked away.
83
:I couldn't even handle, you
know, like waiting for my change.
84
:And so that was the moment where.
85
:My symptoms kind of became more real
and turned into, you know, two months
86
:of not sleeping at all, a very much
kind of cognitive symptoms of brain fog,
87
:feeling very overwhelmed very easily.
88
:I was running a large clinic with
two different locations and a big
89
:staff of acupuncturists, massage
therapists, medical billers, front
90
:office, you know, the whole thing.
91
:And so my experience of having concussion
symptoms was that I was, I was very
92
:much in the fog of it and I didn't
know that that's what was happening.
93
:I just knew that I was struggling and
I didn't even recognize that what I was
94
:dealing with was post-concussion syndrome
until I, this is kind of a very strange
95
:event that happened, but somehow I heard
about this book called The League of
96
:Denial, which was the, the journalistic
book that the movie concussion with
97
:Will Smith was kind of based upon really
the same story of, the researchers
98
:who were, who were studying chronic
traumatic encephalopathy and looking at
99
:NFL players and, and that whole thing.
100
:So I read that book and it was like
a light bulb went off in my brain
101
:and I started to think back to.
102
:I remember that time I got kicked in the
head and I ended up on the floor with
103
:nausea and dizziness and headaches and
oh, I remember that time I was learning
104
:how to wakeboard and I got really dizzy
and I was out of it for a few days after
105
:I crashed over and over and over again.
106
:And oh yeah, there was that one time
when I crashed my mountain bike and
107
:I started to think back and I just
realized, oh wow, I can count probably
108
:seven definite concussions that I've had.
109
:and like I said, two of them
that were 10 days apart.
110
:And so that's what led me to decide
to, I mean, make a radical decision
111
:on shutting down my entire life as it
existed and moving to Texas, going back
112
:to school, studying brain injuries,
and getting my doctorate degree.
113
:And so my.
114
:My education after about eight
years of being in practice
115
:just took a complete 180.
116
:And instead of specializing in fertility,
I've now been studying neurology and
117
:neuroscience and, clinical neuroscience.
118
:And that's been the focus
of my, my personal practice
119
:too, for the last 10 years.
120
:For sure.
121
:MIke: Hmm.
122
:Yeah, that's, it's so interesting when,
you know, the pieces of the puzzle start
123
:to kind of come together and with that
additional personal realization, sort
124
:of kindling the passion to really get,
interested and involved in translating
125
:the challenges that you went through
into your helping other people to
126
:overcome similar challenges, right?
127
:Ayla: Yeah, absolutely.
128
:MIke: And so I guess for maybe for viewers
and listeners who don't necessarily have
129
:a significant background in neuroscience,
maybe help us understand certain
130
:fundamentals like, what would be a way
of understanding what happens to the
131
:brain physiologically after a concussion?
132
:Ayla: Yeah.
133
:And we can absolutely talk about kind
of what happens in the acute stage
134
:and then what can happen afterwards,
which is be where it becomes
135
:kind of infinitely more complex.
136
:I always say that, you know, a
brain injury is the most complicated
137
:injury you can have because the brain
does so many different functions.
138
:And so for every single person,
their experience of a brain injury
139
:can be completely different.
140
:But initially after a brain injury,
there is a metabolic crisis where
141
:because of changes in blood flow
and changes in, blood brain barrier,
142
:permeability and changes in all these
ions in the brain between sodium and
143
:potassium, you can have a huge amount
of, influx of, calcium into parts of
144
:the brain where it doesn't belong.
145
:That creates problems with
the sodium potassium pump.
146
:And so you have this huge
neurotransmitter imbalance that
147
:causes a lot of neurons to depolarize.
148
:And so you've got this huge amount
of metabolic activity that happens
149
:all of a sudden, and that's what
creates this energy deficit.
150
:And so there's an energy deficit in
the brain, which then is why many
151
:people over maybe 10 days to maybe 30
days, feel like they've got brain fog,
152
:difficulty focusing, concentrating.
153
:They've got all these kind of
cognitive symptoms, they've got the
154
:light sensitivity, the headaches,
the sensitivity to movement.
155
:All of that is because the brain
is in a hyperexcitable state.
156
:And that should calm down.
157
:Like a lot of that stuff is
supposed to calm down and kind
158
:of return back to baseline.
159
:And the reality is that most
people, if they get a concussion,
160
:they have a whole health history
behind that concussion, right?
161
:Some people might have Lyme disease,
other people might have an autoimmune
162
:disorder, somebody might suffer from PTSD.
163
:And so what happens is that when
we look at the literature, a lot of
164
:times the literature is looking at
healthy young athletes that maybe
165
:don't have that medical history, right?
166
:They're healthy, and then
they got a sports concussion.
167
:And so I think for the longest time.
168
:we were looking at concussions through
this athletic lens and saying, oh, people,
169
:they generally get better pretty quickly
and, and they can go back to eventually
170
:like, playing their sports again and,
they're good, they're back in school.
171
:But the reality and the demographic
of people that I work with are the
172
:people who have a whole health history
that was there before they got their
173
:car accident or their slip and fall
on the ice or, whatever it might
174
:be that caused their concussion.
175
:And so most of the people I work with
are maybe women in their forties,
176
:fifties, and sixties, that you're never
just treating an acute concussion.
177
:You're obviously treating the whole person
with everything that comes with that.
178
:So there are these very well-defined acute
things that happen after a concussion.
179
:And when people are lucky, they can
get back to baseline and their symptoms
180
:just get better and better and they're
able to go back to work, go back to
181
:school, and return to their normal lives.
182
:Those are generally not the
people that I see in my practice.
183
:The people that I see and the people
that I work with are the people who,
184
:have symptoms that maybe come on
gradually or their symptoms come on
185
:right away and they just never go away.
186
:And they kind of actually
get worse over time.
187
:And so the people that I work with,
often struggle in many different ways.
188
:They may have chronic daily post-traumatic
headaches, chronic neck pain, light
189
:sensitivity, sound sensitivity.
190
:Lots of cognitive symptoms where they
struggle with, doing multitasking all day
191
:long, things that maybe they used to be
great at their job are now very difficult
192
:being in front of screens all day long,
having to process auditory information,
193
:visual information, all of their kind
of cognitive processing is skewed.
194
:And then they may have, some
people have a lot of autonomic
195
:instability and so they've got
abnormal responses to being upright.
196
:So they have orthostatic intolerance
or they've got problems with, how
197
:their brain is controlling their
blood pressure, or they're sweating,
198
:or all kinds of autonomic functions.
199
:And so we have to start looking at
people, and saying, this is, they've
200
:had a concussion or they've had some
type of brain injury, and so we almost
201
:have to kind of set that aside and
say, let's run this person through all
202
:kinds of functional exams to see how is
that manifesting for this individual.
203
:And so that's where the functional
neurology brings a level of individualism
204
:to the treatment plan, to, to the
assessment and the treatment plan that I
205
:think is, can be very profound for people
because you're never just implementing
206
:one specific protocol for everybody.
207
:Everybody is getting a very individualized
treatment plan based on what you see
208
:in that functional neurological exam.
209
:MIke: Yeah, I appreciate
your explanations.
210
:You know, it's understandably complex.
211
:'cause this is such a
complex challenge, right?
212
:I mean, I think the width and
breadth of the symptom distribution
213
:that you're describing and the
complexity, it's incredible.
214
:And it's interesting though in terms
of your background with starting out
215
:with that interest and expertise in
the holistic, the Chinese medicine
216
:background and, and sort of bridging
that with the cutting edge neuroscience,
217
:expertise in terms of, the functional
neurology that you're just talking about.
218
:That makes total sense in terms
of the best way to approach
219
:that kind of thing, right?
220
:Because people are so complex and they're
bringing their complex histories to
221
:this, as you say, not necessarily as
healthy and clean as high performance
222
:athletes who get concussions.
223
:Right?
224
:So that's, it makes sense also
that that's just that the athletic
225
:concussion piece is just a very small
slice of the overall pie in terms of
226
:post-concussive syndrome and then this
persistent post-concussion syndrome.
227
:It's such a challenging topic, isn't it?
228
:Because I think, I can imagine that a
big challenge as well for many people is
229
:the sense of stigma around, having such
complex and sometimes nebulous kind of
230
:vague symptoms and then, considerations
like insurers or employers not buying
231
:into the idea that they're so impaired
because they don't maybe seem so impaired
232
:from the outside objectively, and there's
all those sorts of considerations and
233
:challenges that then also feed into
the mental health problems, right?
234
:Like the demoralization and
the anxiety and the depression.
235
:So it's so complicated.
236
:Ayla: It's very complicated.
237
:And that's exactly, it is sometimes
it's frustrating to feel like.
238
:Just because the research says, well, 70%
of people that get a concussion, go on.
239
:They heal and they can
go on with their lives.
240
:And then the insurance kind of pretends
that that other 30% doesn't exist.
241
:And so those people that have those
persistent concussion symptoms
242
:do often feel abandoned by.
243
:The insurance model.
244
:And the other thing I see happen
a lot 'cause I do work with people
245
:that have had say, motor vehicle
or workers' compensation claims,
246
:is that in those, in instances, a
lot of their treatments are siloed.
247
:And so somebody that has a concussion
and has a lot of different symptoms, they
248
:might see a neurologist that's prescribing
medications for their headaches or their
249
:nausea and then they see, uh, an eye
doctor to address some of the vision.
250
:Issues, and maybe they're put in prisms or
they're, taught different eye exercises,
251
:or they go to an occupational therapist
who maybe gives them some eye exercises,
252
:and then they go to a speech therapist
that does some cognitive exercises,
253
:and then they go to a vestibular
therapist who works on their balance.
254
:And so they do all of these things
and they have all these appointments,
255
:and then they're still not better.
256
:And so that person, when they walk into
my clinic, they've already had their
257
:symptoms for maybe two to five years.
258
:They've already worked with all
the kind of different providers
259
:that they've been told that they
have to go work with, because if
260
:they don't, they're not compliant.
261
:And then their case gets dropped, right?
262
:Mm-hmm.
263
:And so by the time they see me,
they're confused because they're
264
:like, I've done all this therapy,
like, why am I not better?
265
:And mm-hmm.
266
:What I'm really discovering over and over
again is that there is a problem with this
267
:siloed way of thinking of, I'm gonna have
you sit here and just do an eye exercise.
268
:I'm gonna have you go over here
and just work on balancing.
269
:I'm gonna have you then go over here and
just do some kind of cognitive exercises.
270
:And so a lot of what I do is this kind
of integrative work of maybe we're
271
:doing, we're having you move your head
one way and your eyes one way while
272
:you're bouncing on a foam pad and we've
got music in the background and I'm
273
:asking you to do simple math equations.
274
:Or maybe I'm having you balance and like
I'm tossing up different colored scarves
275
:and you have to name the colors of it and
then you have to go do this other thing.
276
:And so a lot of like the
active rehab that I do.
277
:Is kind of engaging all these different
parts of their brain at the same time.
278
:So they're having to think cognitively
balance, turn their head, move
279
:their eyes, be exposed to, you
know, sound or lights or whatever,
280
:and, it's, and all of a sudden they
start to get better and, mm-hmm.
281
:So the, the thing that I think is
frustrating is that all of those
282
:other therapies weren't wrong.
283
:They weren't bad therapies, they
were just not integrating all
284
:the different parts of the brain.
285
:They were kind of, people's
brains learn how to compensate.
286
:And so if you have them just do one
exercise at a time, like an eye exercise,
287
:maybe you're just fueling a compensation
pathway and you're not actually
288
:getting the brain to kind of think
differently about how to do something.
289
:And so, I think there's just the
cases that walk in my door are kind of
290
:these complex persistent cases where
they've typically done a lot of other
291
:therapies and I get to come in and
just say, okay, how do we do things
292
:very differently that gets all these
parts of the brain firing at once.
293
:MIke: Yeah, that's fantastic.
294
:I think it's super interesting,
but it totally makes sense because
295
:it must be just, modeling how.
296
:We just have to react to our
environment all the time without
297
:really thinking too much about it, it's
simulating more of like a real world
298
:kind of rehabilitative experience.
299
:Right.
300
:As opposed to just
301
:Ayla: being compartmentalized as you say.
302
:Because we don't live for the most
part in a very compartmentalized
303
:way or so intentionally like that.
304
:So that, that totally makes sense.
305
:So I'm curious, it makes me think that
the whole idea of functional neurology
306
:kind of relates to exactly that.
307
:Is that correct?
308
:How would you help us to understand this?
309
:Yeah.
310
:Concept of functional neurology.
311
:Yeah.
312
:I like to explain it that it's
functional neurology is a, a mindset.
313
:and just like with, with functional
medicine, you know, I would say, you
314
:know, a great example is, is the thyroid.
315
:so in kind of our modern biomedical
system, people come in, they say,
316
:man, I'm, I've gained weight.
317
:I can't lose it.
318
:I'm lethargic.
319
:I, my metabolism sucks.
320
:And so then the, the doc maybe does some
basic lab work and just looks at their
321
:TSH and says, oh, your TSH is fine.
322
:Your thyroid's fine.
323
:And so that's kind of like this
very, I would say, outdated, lazy
324
:model of assessing the thyroid.
325
:Then that same person might go to a,
a functional medicine provider and
326
:they say, oh, we're gonna run, you
know, TSH and T three and T four and
327
:free T three, and we're gonna look
at reverse T three and we're gonna
328
:look at infl inflammation markers.
329
:We're gonna look at your in, see
if there's any anemia, and then
330
:maybe even if their levels are
kind of within the normal range.
331
:That functional medicine provider
might say, well, you know, you're
332
:still symptomatic and so maybe this
normal range is actually too large
333
:and we have our functional ranges
where we really would like to see you.
334
:And so now we're gonna do some tweaking to
kind of get you into these more functional
335
:ranges where you actually feel better.
336
:And so functional
neurology is the same way.
337
:It's not, let me just run you
through a basic cranial nerve exam
338
:and say, you know, can you feel my
finger on your trigeminal nerve?
339
:And can you follow my
thumb back and forth?
340
:And, well, your pursuits, they're,
they're intact even though
341
:maybe they don't look great.
342
:you know, functional neurology is
really about assessing the person.
343
:With all these kind of individual,
systems like the autonomic system
344
:and the ocular motor system and the
vestibular system, but then also
345
:saying like real world scenario.
346
:Well, you might be able to bAylance just
fine standing there with your eyes closed.
347
:But what happens if I start
playing music in your ear?
348
:Do you lose your bAylance?
349
:you know, we can like have somebody walk
down the hall and look at their gate and
350
:then have them walk down the hall and
say every other letter of the alphabet
351
:and all of a sudden they're falling
over and they're freezing and they've
352
:lost their arm swing and they're like
doing weird thing bobblehead things.
353
:And it's like you watch
their gate completely change.
354
:When you just ask them to walk down the
hall and, and think at the same time.
355
:And so functional neurology is about,
let's take this person, do all of these
356
:tests in isolation, but then also do
them in these kind of contexts of what
357
:happens to your eyes when you, your
head is tilted into a certain like, you
358
:know, semi-circular connect position
or what happens to your motor system.
359
:one of the tests I love to do is, you
know, there's the classic, you know,
360
:touch your finger and then touch my nose.
361
:Well, I like to have people, you know,
touch their nose and then touch my finger
362
:and go back and forth three times and
then I have 'em close their eyes and
363
:do it again with their eyes closed.
364
:And then I compare that to what
happens if your head is tilted
365
:back into the right or straight to
the right or down into the right.
366
:And so I start testing that
exact same test with their
367
:head in different positions.
368
:And sometimes you find that their motor
coordination completely breaks down
369
:when they're biasing a semi-circular
canal that's maybe under firing.
370
:And so functional neurology is the process
of kind of running all these scenarios
371
:to say, what happens if we do this?
372
:What happens if we put
you in that situation?
373
:What happens if you have to do
this and that at the same time?
374
:And then we start to figure out,
ooh, here's where the system breaks
375
:down and here's how we can craft a
creative individual kind of rehab
376
:strategy to, to work these kinks out
and to get your system to be able to
377
:operate in those environments better.
378
:MIke: Hmm.
379
:Yeah.
380
:That's awesome.
381
:I mean, the, the, the term
that stands out to me is the
382
:individualized kind of approach, right?
383
:Because I think part of what, you
know, and I think this is part of a
384
:frustration particularly, dare I say
in the Canadian healthcare system,
385
:where it's kinda like, take it or
leave it to a certain extent with, in
386
:terms of like how you get investigated
and what treatments get offered.
387
:And I think as you say, part of it
is, it's kind of an institutional
388
:barrier as far as, you know, trying
to, there's a reason why it's important
389
:to a certain extent to kind of.
390
:Try and put people into these cubby
holes in terms of diagnostics.
391
:But, but that, that doesn't mean to say
that you're always gonna be capturing
392
:their true symptoms or putting them on a
path to getting relief of those symptoms.
393
:Right.
394
:So this kind of approach that you're
describing is much more, attentive to
395
:those individual symptoms and these
individual client stories as opposed
396
:to the actual lab result number, right?
397
:It's like, treat the client,
not, not the number that you get
398
:back on the lab result, right?
399
:Ayla: Mm-hmm.
400
:Yeah.
401
:Yeah.
402
:And a lot of these people are people who
have, you know, graduated from something
403
:like vestibular physical therapy because
they were able to kind of pass all the
404
:tests, but then they'll say, well, by the
end of the day when I'm tired, like I'm
405
:still just falling all over the place.
406
:Or when I go into the grocery store,
all of a sudden my bAylance falls apart.
407
:And so they might be able to perform
certain tests just fine, but then
408
:you put them in a different situation
and then they wouldn't be able to,
409
:And the reality is that the work
that I do is very time consuming.
410
:You know, I spend, I do spend a ton
of time with each individual person,
411
:and I know that our medical system
just isn't necessarily designed
412
:for, for that type of care, so,
413
:mm-hmm.
414
:MIke: Yeah, sure.
415
:That, and that's a very
valid point for sure.
416
:It's a matter of suppose of finding
that bAylance, but, yeah, no, I'm sure
417
:your clients really appreciate the
attentiveness and the time that you
418
:spend with them, and I'm sure that
has a lot to do with the outcomes that
419
:you find, you know, the improvements,
the, the ability to individualize the
420
:rehabilitation programs for people.
421
:I'm super curious about, you know,
these, these more holistic approaches
422
:like the acupuncture and how it might
optimize things like cerebral blood flow.
423
:I understand that that's a, a, a
specific aspect of your research
424
:and your clinical interest.
425
:Could you explain a little
bit about that for us?
426
:Ayla: Yeah, that was, a big part of kinda
where I started on my journey of, of
427
:learning all of this and, and studying
the brain, was that I was trying to
428
:figure out is there a, a place, is there
a role for acupuncture in brain injuries?
429
:And a lot of the research that
existed was more on stroke because
430
:in China, acupuncture is, very much
heavily utilized in stroke recovery.
431
:And so a lot of the, the
research was looking at the, the.
432
:Mechanisms of acupuncture for
people that have had, strokes,
433
:which is a type of brain injury.
434
:And also, there was research
on acupuncture for spinal
435
:cord injury as well.
436
:And so I was looking at a lot of that
literature and then looking at a lot
437
:of the literature on does acupuncture
improve blood flow in the brain?
438
:And if so, kind of what are
the different mechanisms?
439
:And so, basically to kind of not get
too technical, our, our trigeminal
440
:vascular system is a pretty vast
network of interaction between the, the
441
:branches of the different trigeminal
nerves and, and all of their offshoots
442
:and then all of our vasculature
within our, our skull and the dura.
443
:And so.
444
:What they're finding is that acupuncture
on the scalp and on the face,
445
:really does have a neuromodulatory
effect on that trigeminovascular
446
:system in a way that it does help
to improve blood flow to the brain.
447
:And so you can use acupuncture as one
tool for not just improving kind of
448
:what we might call global blood flow,
but also regional blood flow as well.
449
:I do think that there's a bit of a, a
wisdom there where blood flow can be
450
:directed to certain parts of the brain.
451
:based on kind of your point location, and
at least at, at the very least we can say
452
:there's certain acupuncture points that
improve blood flow through the anterior
453
:circulation, through that carotid,
and then also, through the posterior
454
:circulation through that basal artery too.
455
:So
456
:MIke: that's, that's so fascinating.
457
:Yeah.
458
:Really, really interesting.
459
:I mean, I guess the other thing that I
was wondering about is in terms of, you
460
:often hear these, I suppose to a certain
extent, myths, I guess I'm not quite sure,
461
:but I'd like your, thoughts about that.
462
:But myths or, or sort of like, you know,
for example, one of the most common
463
:pieces of advice that I think people
might often hear after sustaining a
464
:concussion is to just kind of go to
a, sit in a dark room and rest and,
465
:and have like a lower stimulation
kind of experience for a while.
466
:I was understanding from reading some of
your writings that that's not always the
467
:best advice after the first few days.
468
:So I guess maybe help us
understand then, Yeah.
469
:In practical terms, what might be
some, I know you can't, you know,
470
:provide specific advice, you know,
and it's complicated, but in general
471
:terms, like why might prolonged
rest be actually counterproductive?
472
:Ayla: Yeah, there's pretty clear
research now that if people sit in a
473
:dark room, that they create a lot of,
negative or maladaptive, neuroplasticity,
474
:the kind that we don't want.
475
:Hmm.
476
:And so what can happen is that if
somebody, well, well, I'll say right
477
:now, the, in the literature, both,
you know, western medicine, biomedical
478
:model, everybody is now pretty
much on the same page and saying,
479
:we understand that rest is not the
answer beyond like 48, maybe 72 hours.
480
:So if you get a concussion kind of
immediately in that 48 hours, you do want
481
:to remove yourself from too much stimuli.
482
:And then after that.
483
:this, it's not okay now you can kind
of go back to work full time or now you
484
:can like go play video games all day.
485
:It's not that, but it's saying,
you do want to get outside and, and
486
:just go for a short walk if you can.
487
:You do want to kind of expose yourself
to some amounts of conversation and
488
:inter interaction with people, and you
wanna move your body in a, in a safe way.
489
:And so now the recommendations are
more of these kind of graded, gradual
490
:return to daily activities and mm-hmm.
491
:also kind of as someone
can daily movement as well.
492
:Because the autonomic
nervous system becomes more
493
:deconditioned, the less we move.
494
:And so the, when we, when we look at
dysautonomia and dysfunction of the
495
:autonomic nervous system exercise is, is
really one of the most powerful ways to
496
:condition the autonomic nervous system.
497
:And so that's where it is
really important to just say.
498
:Hey, even if you have a headache,
can you go for a super slow walk
499
:or can you just get outside?
500
:Can you move your body a little bit, in a
way that isn't like making your headache
501
:go from a five outta 10 to a 10 outta 10?
502
:And so we kind of take this like two point
increase of pain on that, you know, zero
503
:to 10 scale and say, can you do something
up until the point where maybe your
504
:headache goes from a five outta 10 to a
seven outta 10, then maybe we back off.
505
:and knowing that some, a little
bit of exacerbation of symptoms
506
:is kind of gonna be that cue of,
okay, I need to take a break.
507
:But it's okay to push a little bit.
508
:as long as you're not putting yourself
in a situation where you could
509
:potentially hit your head a second time.
510
:right.
511
:So obviously safe
controlled environments, but
512
:Gradually returning to
activities is really important.
513
:even if symptoms do exacerbate just a
little bit, there is research that says
514
:the people who did kind of go back to
work part-time at least, ended up with
515
:better outcomes than the people that like
didn't go back at all and, and really
516
:just sat and did nothing for six months.
517
:And so it's important to use the brain.
518
:It's important to move the body.
519
:it's important to get nutrition in, and
during those kind of acute initial stages,
520
:even if it does cause a little, you know,
some increase in symptoms, the outcomes
521
:are just better than sitting in the
dark room and not doing anything at all.
522
:MIke: Yeah, that's really
helpful to understand, this
523
:whole idea of dysautonomia and
the autonomic system regulation.
524
:Maybe, if you don't mind, you
know, explaining a little bit
525
:about the autonomic system and
what dysautonomia is and, and what.
526
:Strategies can be helpful to,
to help with rehabilitation
527
:regarding that particular system?
528
:Ayla: Yeah, I think it's important
to kind of differentiate between
529
:what we might call autonomic nervous
system dysregulation, versus a, a
530
:medical condition of dysautonomia.
531
:Okay.
532
:because many people are walking around,
very stressed out, you know, traumatic
533
:experiences, post-traumatic stress.
534
:There's a lot of people that probably
do have some level of autonomic
535
:dysregulation, but maybe not a, a
medical diagnosis of dysautonomia.
536
:So those are two separate things.
537
:dysautonomia has gotten a lot more,
eyes on it lately because of COVID
538
:and the fact that an exposure to
a virus can cause dysautonomia.
539
:and one specific type of it is postural
orthostatic tachycardia syndrome.
540
:And so, POTS as a subtype of
dysautonomia got a lot of attention
541
:in the last five, six years, because
of the fact that it could be triggered
542
:by a virus and by an illness.
543
:And so, that is like a very
specific form of dysautonomia.
544
:Where when you stand up, your heart
rate goes up more than 30 beats
545
:per minute, and it's gonna have an
inaccurate response to someone just
546
:going from laying down to standing.
547
:And that increased heart rate is
actually a compensation for other
548
:things that are going wrong within
the autonomic nervous system.
549
:And so that's also part of the problem
with pots is that simply just trying
550
:to squash an elevated heart rate isn't
necessarily fixing the root problem.
551
:'cause the heart rate is really
just a compensation for other things
552
:that aren't happening correctly.
553
:and there's different subtypes
of pots to get into an even more
554
:kind of complex, picture there.
555
:But our autonomic nervous system.
556
:I like to explain it like it, you
know, we talk about parasympathetic
557
:as this rest and digest and feeling
relaxed and, and the sympathetic
558
:is kind of like being stressed out.
559
:But in reality, the sympathetic
nervous system is just as
560
:important as the parasympathetic.
561
:And we, we need to have a
sympathetic response if we
562
:want to be able to exercise.
563
:And so a, a highly responsive, intact,
autonomic nervous system is making
564
:appropriate responses to the moment.
565
:And so the example I like to use is, I
know I live out in the country, there are
566
:dear everywhere, and so I can't tell you
how many times I'm driving home from work.
567
:The sun has just gone down and a deer
jumps out right in front of my car, right?
568
:Mm-hmm.
569
:And so a normal response is I slam on
my brakes, my heart starts pounding.
570
:I maybe like, stop
breathing for a second, but.
571
:If I have an intact autonomic nervous
system, I can say, okay, the deer's gone.
572
:Nobody's hit me.
573
:I didn't hit the deer.
574
:I'm fine.
575
:Everybody's fine.
576
:I'm gonna keep driving and I can get, I
can get my breath under control and I can
577
:bring my heart rate down pretty quickly.
578
:And so that is my autonomic nervous
system, having a normal response to
579
:having to slam on my brakes and a
very quick return to baseline where
580
:I'm like, okay, I'm safe, we're good.
581
:Everything's fine.
582
:Mm-hmm.
583
:Somebody with dysautonomia that
happens and boom, they might
584
:have extreme headaches, nausea,
dizziness, neck pain, fatigue.
585
:They might have to go lay down
for four hours and their system
586
:can't get back to that baseline,
because it's so dysregulated.
587
:And so we have to think about our
autonomic nervous system as just.
588
:When it's working well, it's
responding appropriately to the moment.
589
:and if the moment requires that
we run away from the, the grizzly
590
:bear, then we really need to
have that sympathetic output.
591
:and so it makes all these beat to beat
adjustments of the heart rate, the blood
592
:pressure, the sweating, pupil size.
593
:And then the autonomic nervous system
also is, has a long-term control over our
594
:immune system and our circadian rhythms.
595
:And so a lot of people with dysautonomia,
they have circadian rhythms that are
596
:off, they have very poor sleep, they
have maybe, an autoimmune component,
597
:because of that kind of failure of the
long-term regulation of immune function.
598
:So there's a lot of overlap between
autoimmunity and dysautonomia.
599
:and that's where, again, like
infections can be something that
600
:just triggers that change and kind of
throws people over the edge as well.
601
:MIke: Hmm.
602
:Yeah.
603
:Thanks for explaining that.
604
:It's, it's so interesting and it
makes me really think that, the way
605
:you explain it in the wide ranging
cascading effects really does help to
606
:under help people to under, hopefully
it helps me to understand, hopefully
607
:it's helping viewers and listeners to
understand that's, this is why, because
608
:it's so pervasive and, and there are
these cascading effects, it makes me
609
:think that that helps to explain the
reason why there can be such significant
610
:and chronic functional impairment.
611
:That kind of seems a bit nebulous
because it's so far reaching.
612
:Does that make sense?
613
:Ayla: Yeah, it does.
614
:And there's a questionnaire
called the Compass 31.
615
:It was developed by the Mayo Clinic, and
it started out as 168 questions where they
616
:were trying to figure out like, here's
all the possible things that could go
617
:wrong with the autonomic nervous system.
618
:They came up with 168 questions,
and then over the course of
619
:using it and finding out, okay.
620
:Which people with dysautonomia, how did
they answer the questionnaire versus
621
:people that didn't, they were able to
narrow it down to 31 key questions.
622
:And those 31 key questions center
around orthostatic intolerance.
623
:You know, what happens when you stand up?
624
:Are you getting dizzy?
625
:Are you having cognitive symptoms?
626
:do you have light sensitivity?
627
:Again, because the, the
pupils are very autonomic.
628
:That pupilary light reflex
is an autonomic reflex.
629
:And so sometimes when people have light
sensitivity, it's kind of, there's
630
:some dysfunction within that reflex.
631
:And then, what we call like secret
credo, motor and vasomotor symptoms.
632
:So things like flushing, like
inappropriate flushing or
633
:hives or things like that.
634
:That occur or an inability to sweat.
635
:Many people with concussions and
post-concussion syndrome will say they
636
:develop heat intolerance, and I think
a big part of that is that underlying
637
:DYS adenoma and the failure to regulate
vasomotor and secret motor functions in
638
:relationship to venting heat from the body
through the opening and closing of the
639
:pores and through sweating mechanisms.
640
:Then there's a whole gastrointestinal,
component to that as well.
641
:And people often develop what we might
call like functional gastrointestinal
642
:disorders where there's no actual
physical obstruction or blockage, but
643
:people have more of like these irritable
bowel type presentations in a lot
644
:of nausea for, for maybe no reason.
645
:Or they eat and they don't feel good.
646
:And the, and so a lot of people
will deal with these kind of
647
:functional GI symptoms as well.
648
:Mm-hmm.
649
:And so the Compass 31 is kind of this
like beautiful tool that can, highlight
650
:the degree to which somebody might have a
higher kind of autonomic symptom burden.
651
:MIke: Mm-hmm.
652
:Yeah, it's, it's very interesting.
653
:Yeah.
654
:It makes me think that, I think, you
know, historically there is kind of a
655
:bias against paying attention to the
autonomic system or even understanding,
656
:even having knowledge about it,
like in western medical training.
657
:So it's, it strikes me that, that,
you know, that there's such importance
658
:there as, as understanding and, and that
representing kind of a bridge to, yeah,
659
:things like how, you know, in psychiatric
terms, maybe the unconscious as well,
660
:because our autonomic functioning is
kind of outside of our, you know, waking
661
:consciousness to a large extent, right?
662
:How the unconscious actually also in
is involved with various different
663
:aspects of mental health and wellness,
but physical health and wellness also.
664
:And furthermore, how these alternative
holistic options like the acupuncture,
665
:you know, Chinese medicine approaches
does in, in a way maybe more inherently
666
:recruit or pay attention to the autonomic
system issues and how to correct those.
667
:Ayla: Yeah, the, there's a, a big kind
of a link between the limbic system
668
:and our autonomic nervous system.
669
:And when people, maybe do feel very
unsafe in their own body because of
670
:a, a history of past trauma that can
keep them in kind of a dysautonomia
671
:state because of that integration of
the limbic system into the autonomics.
672
:And so people's emotions and feelings
and, and history of, of trauma can play
673
:a huge role in, in dysautonomia patterns.
674
:And yet, yeah, a lot of times.
675
:That's not how medicine
always looks at it.
676
:They just kinda look at, oh, here's
this, here's this very stressed out
677
:hypochondriac who has, you know,
a list of 40 different complaints.
678
:And it's like, well, when you look
at those 40 different complaints,
679
:probably 35 of them are related
to autonomic functions, you know?
680
:Mm-hmm.
681
:And so a lot of times I think people can
get gaslit into thinking that, there's
682
:really nothing wrong with them, and
they're just making it up and they're
683
:confused and then they lose hope.
684
:And so I think that my goal with writing
my book was really to give people hope.
685
:You know, my book was written
for the people who have, you
686
:know, probably already seen a
number of different doctors.
687
:They've been dealing with these
lingering symptoms for a long time.
688
:They've probably tried a lot of
medications, and I'm not anti-medication,
689
:but there are no FDA approved
drugs for post-concussion syndrome.
690
:And so every single drug
that is being prescribed.
691
:Is symptom management.
692
:And so I'm not being anti-medicine, I'm
just saying this is what, that we don't
693
:have a post-concussion syndrome drug yet.
694
:Mm-hmm.
695
:And all of the pharmaceuticals are,
are more treating a symptom, whether
696
:it's a headache or nausea or anxiety.
697
:And in some cases that works.
698
:But when that doesn't work, my book was
written for the people who are like,
699
:I feel like I've run out of options.
700
:Like what else is out there?
701
:mm-hmm.
702
:And that kind of brings us to the whole
topic of, you know, neuromodulation.
703
:And, in some cases acupuncture can be
a very gentle tool for modulating the
704
:autonomic nervous system and, helping
to promote more parasympathetic tone.
705
:If you look at the research over the last
20 years, the systematic reviews that
706
:have done that work have really said yes.
707
:The totality of acupuncture
research shows that it can shift
708
:people from a sympathetic state
into a parasympathetic state.
709
:Mm-hmm.
710
:That's where I think
also frequency matters.
711
:and what else is somebody also doing
to help kind of with stress management?
712
:And I often refer people out
for EMDR and counseling and, and
713
:all these other therapies that,
that address all of this stuff.
714
:So it's like mm-hmm.
715
:Acupuncture is just one tool and it's, it
can be very effective for certain things,
716
:but I, I always look at it as really just
one tool amongst many that exist and often
717
:we have to have a, a multidisciplinary
approach to, to helping people.
718
:MIke: Yeah, no, thanks very much for that.
719
:And I was just gonna ask about your book.
720
:So, for viewers and listeners,
the concussion breakthrough, and
721
:it's been called the Concussion
Bible, very comprehensive.
722
:you know, very, very helpful.
723
:I really encourage people to take
advantage of, of the wisdom and the
724
:knowledge that's, that's in there.
725
:And I think, yeah, I appreciate you
explaining that, you know, these are
726
:the intended, readers and, and, and
how you're intending to help them.
727
:What, what would be some, perhaps maybe
some major misconceptions that you're
728
:trying to correct in the book and,
and, and what would you rather than,
729
:you know, be hoping that people take
away from the book in, in a nutshell?
730
:Ayla: Yeah.
731
:I kind of see it as a bit of a choose
your own adventure in, I think.
732
:Somebody.
733
:so in chapter one, people can take a
ques, like a symptom questionnaire,
734
:and I've divided the book into kind of
symptom categories, but it's a bit of
735
:a trick because somebody might say, if
they have post-traumatic headaches, they
736
:might read the chapter on post-traumatic
headaches and realize, oh, well maybe my
737
:neck injury is partly part of the problem,
so now I have to read chapter two.
738
:Or maybe there's something wrong
with my, my eye movements and I
739
:have an undiagnosed eye movement
disorder that's driving my headaches.
740
:Now I have to go read that chapter.
741
:So it's a bit of a choose your own
adventure, where I hope that as
742
:people kind of take the survey.
743
:And if whatever category they're scoring
highest in, they can go read that chapter.
744
:But very likely they're gonna learn all
of these different associations between,
745
:well, maybe my eyes are problematic
because I have some vestibular imbAylance
746
:that's driving my eyes to have nystagmus.
747
:Or maybe this is partly why I am
dealing with that, or maybe my
748
:autonomic dysfunction is what's causing
some of these cognitive symptoms.
749
:And so my hope with the book is people
start to have a much broader picture
750
:of what they're dealing with and
what all of these different factors
751
:are that maybe haven't been fully
addressed yet to give them a new path
752
:forward if they're feeling stuck.
753
:And I think that's my, my,
that was my number one goal
754
:was whoever's feeling stuck.
755
:If they read this book, I, I imagine
that they're gonna find something that
756
:they can look further into to help them
take that next step on their journey.
757
:MIke: That's fantastic.
758
:That's so amazing and so inspiring.
759
:thanks so much for writing the book.
760
:I'm sure that you have helped and
you're gonna continue to help many,
761
:many people through your clinical
work, through, through the wisdom
762
:and the knowledge in your book.
763
:So thanks so much for that.
764
:Dr.
765
:Wolf.
766
:This has been a fascinating conversation.
767
:what really stands out to me from our
discussion is that concussion recovery is
768
:certainly far more complex than that kind
of legacy, traditional rest and weight
769
:model that many people might think about.
770
:Um.
771
:Yeah, just, it's so inspiring.
772
:I mean, your work really highlights
to me how the brain is such
773
:an incredibly dynamic system.
774
:You know, one that can heal
when we understand how, you
775
:know, people are individuals.
776
:We all have our individual story,
and how that individual story
777
:needs to be integrated into a
comprehensive rehabilitation plan.
778
:And, you know, one that supports
things like you've mentioned,
779
:neuroplasticity, circulation, autonomic
regulation, brain network functioning.
780
:So thanks again.
781
:And so, again, for viewers and
listeners who want to learn more
782
:about your work, we're gonna put
links in the show notes, where you
783
:can find out how to, get access to Dr.
784
:Wolf's book, her podcast as well.
785
:So again, the book is The
Concussion Breakthrough.
786
:Discover The Missing Pieces to Recovery.
787
:And Dr.
788
:Wolf's podcast is Life After Impact,
the Concussion Recovery Podcast.
789
:Dr.
790
:Wolf, thank you so much
for joining me today.
791
:thanks everyone for listening.
792
:yeah, thanks Dr.
793
:Wolf.
794
:Just really, really appreciate
your time and your wisdom and,
795
:such an inspiring message.
796
:So thank you.
797
:Ayla: Thank you for having me.
798
:I, this is again, my, my favorite topic
to share information on because it is
799
:so complex and I just hope I can, like I
said, give people kind of one new insight
800
:that they can take with them and, and
help them on their recovery journey.
801
:So thanks for that opportunity.
802
:MIke: Awesome.
803
:Yeah.
804
:Thank you so much.
805
:And so, for viewers and listeners, if
you have enjoyed this episode, please
806
:like, and subscribe, share the episode
with friends, family members, colleagues,
807
:anyone you think that might benefit.
808
:feel free to leave comments, or
review, helps others discover
809
:these important conversations
about the future of brain Health.
810
:And until next time, we'll see you,
again on the Neurostimulation Podcast.
811
:Take care, stay curious and be well.
812
:Thanks so much.
